Facebook Places could spark new privacy fire

Having to opt out instead of opting in makes some unhappy about Facebook’s new location-based app

On Wednesday, Facebook took the wraps off of Places, a smartphone-based service that enables users to tell their friends where they are, and to track friends. The service, which is slowly being rolled out to users, enables people to share their friends’ locations.

Forcing users to opt out of using the service rather than allowing them to opt in has some privacy advocates up in arms. Facebook has set up Places so that it is on by default, and users must make their way through the system’s privacy controls in order to turn it off.

“I’ve watched how they’ve handled users’ privacy over the last year and a half or so, and they continually step on their dance partners’ feet every time they get a new dance partner,” said Brad Shimmin, an analyst at Current Analysis.

“The fact that it’s turned on by default really ticks me off as a user. Those missteps bother me and show that they really are running a little bit faster than they know how,” Shimmin continued. “They keep requiring users to jump over hoops to protect themselves.”

While there hasn’t been widespread outrage over the new feature, Shimmin wasn’t the only one who was angry about it. Soon after Facebook announced Places, the ACLU of Northern California issued a statement saying the social network has failed to build in some important safeguards.

“In the world of Facebook Places, ‘no’ is unfortunately not an option,” the ACLU said in the statement. “Places allows your friends to tag you when they check in somewhere, and Facebook makes it very easy to say ‘yes’ to allowing your friends to check in for you. But when it comes to opting out of that feature, you are only given a ‘not now’ option. ‘No’ isn’t one of the easy options.”

Facebook spokesman Barry Schnitt fired back today, saying he’s “disappointed” in the ACLU of Northern California. “Facebook Places sets a new standard for user control and privacy protection for location information,” he wrote in a statement.

“No one can be checked in to a location without their explicit permission. Many third parties have applauded our controls, indicating that people have more protections using Facebook Places than other widely used location services available today,” Schnitt said.